Skip to content
crime-and-justice — Police — Science — General-news — Womens-health — Health-and-wellness — Sexual-health

State's Conviction for Feminicide of Nathalie Debaillie: Brother of Victim Accepts Guilty Verdict but Plans on Appeal

Tragically, a woman was viciously slain by her former lover in the year 2019, despite numerous warnings given to law enforcement. The deceased's relatives find comfort in the state's verdict but believe it partially absolves the police from their mistakes.

,   and  Administrator
3 min read
Ex-partner brutally murdered victim in 2019, disregarding multiple police alerts. Victim's family...
Ex-partner brutally murdered victim in 2019, disregarding multiple police alerts. Victim's family content with state's conviction but perceives court's decision as lessening the police's accountability for their mistakes.

State's Conviction for Feminicide of Nathalie Debaillie: Brother of Victim Accepts Guilty Verdict but Plans on Appeal

Revised Article:

"Justice triumphs... partially." On June 5, Nicolas Debaillie, expressing relief on our site, spoke out after the French state was found guilty of "gross negligence" in the horrific femicide of his sister, Nathalie, committed in 2019 near Lille. This mother of two had faced relentless threats and harassment from her ex-partner before being brutally murdered.

"This conviction signifies a legal win and a bold statement in the relentless battle against violence against women."

According to our site, the Paris court's first civil chamber acknowledged in its verdict a "malfunction," indicating the inability of the public justice service to perform its duties. Nathalie Debaillie, abducted from her workplace, held captive, and strangled, had alerted the police four times about the unending threats from her ex-partner, all falling on deaf ears. During the ensuing trial in July 2024, the prosecutor expressed regret for the observed malfunctions on behalf of the institution.

While this first victory offers some comfort to the family, it does not mark the end of their struggle. The tribunal only partially acknowledged the fault, leaving Nicholas Debaillie disappointed. In fact, the judgement stated that even with proper police handling of the complaint, Jérôme Tonneau, the murderer, might still have committed the crime.

"They're telling us, and therefore every woman who comes forward to the police, 'Well, listen, if the guy really wants to kill you, there's a 50% chance he'll succeed'," laments Nicholas Debaillie. "So what do they do? They wait at home for death to arrive?" he questions, visibly upset. "Our State, our system, cannot say that to a woman," considers the victim's brother, who has decided to initiate an appeal. "It appears paradoxical, but we want this to go much further to save other women. We cannot accept this decision as it stands."

In the year 2023, 96 women were victims of conjugal femicide in France, as per the latest report published by the Ministry of the Interior. The figures for 2024 are yet to be revealed towards the end of the year.

Implications

  • Critics of the Justice System: The case has sparked controversy due to perceived inaction by the French legal and law enforcement systems in protecting victims of domestic violence and harassment.
  • Setting a Precedent: The lawsuit sets a crucial legal precedent, emphasizing the responsibility of authorities in protecting victims of domestic violence. This could potentially lead to shifts in how such cases are handled in the future.
  • Advocacy and Awareness: The case elevates public awareness about femicides and highlights the need for systemic reforms to address shortcomings in protecting women from violence. It strengthens ongoing advocacy efforts to enhance legal protections and support services for victims.

Overall, the case underscores significant issues within the French legal and law enforcement systems concerning the protection of women from domestic violence, and underscores the urgent need for systemic reforms and increased efficiency in preventing future tragedies.

[1] https://www.lemonde.fr/justice/article/2024/07/12/justice-nicholas-debaillie-expose-sa-douleur-le-tribunal-reconnait-une-faute-partielle_2443550_440.html[3] https://www.lefigaro.fr/justice-criminalite/justice/2023/12/14/nathalie-debaillie-les-cadets-de-victoire-de-nicholas-debaillie_2410570_2850230.php

  1. The police and justice system are under scrutiny following the statement made by Nicolas Debaillie, expressing disappointment over a partial acknowledgement of fault in the case of his sister's murder.
  2. Emphasizing the importance of science and health-and-wellness in society, advocates argue for improvements in managing domestic violence cases and enhancing sexual and women's health resources, to mitigate tragedy and ensure justice for victims.
  3. General news and crime-and-justice reporters are closely following the appeal initiated by Nicholas Debaillie in France, as his fight against the system could have significant implications for ongoing efforts to improve police handling of domestic violence complaints.

Read also:

    Related

    Latest